Gadget by The Blog Doctor.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Negative times Negative equals Positive

Those with some familiarity with secondary school maths will be aware that a negative number multiplied by a negative number gives a positive number.

For example:
-2 X -3 = +6 , it does not equal -6.

I thought that rule was an axiom or assumption. An equivalent in standard English is the double negative. The statement "I don't want nothing" means that you want something because whatever you don't want it isn't nothing. Of cause in colloquial English and other versions of English it can still mean a negative. As well a double negative can mean negative in some other languages, for example Africans and Greek.

The Distributive Law
In mathematics though negative times negative equals positive turns out to be a provable law. The first issue to deal with is the Distributive Law of Mathematics, which can be written as : A x C + B x C = (A + B) x C . Stated in words the distributive law says: to multiply a given number C by the sum of two numbers is the same as multiplying C by each of those numbers and and then adding the result. The Distributive Law links multiplication with addition and is one of the fundamental laws of maths.

Here is a demonstration of how the law works with positive whole numbers.

If A = 2, B = 3 and C = 4:
2 x 4 + 3 x 4 = (2 + 3) x 4
8 + 12 = 5 x 4
20 = 20

There are algebraic proofs of the Distributive Law, but they require considerable explanation. As a visual thinker I find the diagram at right compelling proof.

Applying the Distributive Law to Negative Numbers
Our task is to apply the distributive law to negative numbers.
When we do this two other rules will be resolved: positive x negative = ? and n
egative x negative = ?.

Positive x Negative = ?
Assume: positive x negative = positive ie -3 x 4 = +12 and -1 x 4 = 4
If A = 2, B = -3, C = 4
By the distributive law:
2 x 4 + -3 x 4 = (2 + -3) x 4
8 + 12 = -1 x 4
20 = 4
This result is clearly incorrect so our assumption (positive X negative = positive) is incorrect.
Assume: positive x negative = negative ie -3 x 4 = -12 and -1 x 4 = -4
By the distributive law:
2 x 4 + -3 x 4 = (2 + -3)x 4
8 + -12 = -1 X 4
-4 = -4
This is clearly correct so our assumption (positive X negative = negative) is correct.

Negative X Negative = ?
Assume: negative x negative = negative ie -3 x -4 = -12 and -1 x -4 = -4
If A = 2, B = -3, C = -4
By the distributive law:
2 x -4 + -3 x -4 = (2 + -3) x -4
-8 + -12 = -1 x -4
-20 = -4
This is clearly incorrect so our assumption (negative x negative = negative) is incorrect.
Assume: negative x negative = positive ie -3 x -4 = 12and -1 x -4 =4
If A = 2, B = -3, C = -4
By the distributive law:
2 x -4 + -3 x -4 = (2 + -3) x -4
-8 + 12 = -1 x -4
4 = 4
This is clearly correct so our assumption (negative x negative = positive) is true which is what we set out to do at the beginning of the post.

A More Concise Proof
The following proof is more shorter than that described above. The only extra mathematical rule that this contains is a number multiplied by zero is equal to zero, ie N x 0 = 0 .

An example is 5 x 0 = 0 which equals 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0
which is of cause 0.

Let a and b be any two real numbers. Consider the number n defined by:
n = ab + (-a)(b) + (-a)(-b)

We can write
n = ab + (-a)[ (b) + (-b) ] (factor out -a)
= ab + (-a) (0)
= ab + 0
= ab

n = [ a + (-a) ]b + (-a)(-b) (factor out b)
= 0 x b + (-a)(-b)
= 0 + (-a)(-b)
= (-a)(-b)

So we have,
n = ab
n = (-a)(-b)

Hence ab = (-a)(-b)

UPDATE: 28 / 01/ 2013

Here is an argument from the Khan Academy using the distributive law, demonstrating that a negative times a negative equals a positive:

Here are two more videos from the Khan Academy explaining negative times negative equals positive.

The first one explains why positive times negative equals negative:

The next video uses ideas from the previous video to demonstrate that negative times negative equals positive:


Marcianne said...

Thank you very much for taking the time to spell this all out.

I have difficulty with math, and this has been one of the more puzzling issues.

I think I understand it now, which is good, because now I can move on with my life. :-)

Anonymous said...

-----------------Proof of Margaret and Stephen, START -----------

Multiplication sign = (.)

[^^^] = [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).(+B) + (-A).(-B) ]

[^^^] = [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).(+B) + (-A).(-B) ]
= [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).{ (+B) + (-B) } ] * (-A)
= [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).{ ( 0 ) } ]
= [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).( 0 ) ]
= [ N = (+A).(+B) + ( 0 ) ]
= [ N = (+A).(+B) ]
= [ N = (+A)(+B) ]
= [ N = (A)(B) ]
= [ N = AB ]

[^^^] = [ N = (+A).(+B) + (-A).(+B) + (-A).(-B) ]
= [ N = (+B).{ (+A) + (-A) } + (-A).(-B) ] * (+B)
= [ N = (+B).{ ( 0 ) } + (-A).(-B) ]
= [ N = (+B).( 0 ) + (-A).(-B) ]
= [ N = ( 0 ) + (-A).(-B) ]
= [ N = (-A).(-B) ]

[^^^] = [ N = AB ]
= [ N = (-A).(-B) ]

[ AB = (-A).(-B) ]

-----------------Proof of Margaret and Stephen, END -----------

-----------------Proof of Liuhui Brahmagupta, START -----------

[^^^] = [ (-a) X (-b) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (-a) } X { (-b) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+a) + (-2a) } X { (+b) + (-2b) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+a) - (+2a) } X { (+b) - (+2b) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+a) - (+2a) } X (+b) - { (+a) - (+2a) } X (+2b) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+ab) - (+2ab) } - { (+2ab) - (+4ab) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+ab) - (+2ab) } - { (+2ab) + (-4ab) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (+ab) - (+2ab) - (+2ab) - (-4ab) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (+ab) - (+2ab) - (+2ab) + (+4ab) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (+ab) + (+4ab) - (+2ab) - (+2ab) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+ab) + (+4ab) } - { (+2ab) + (+2ab) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ { (+5ab) } - { (+4ab) } = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (+5ab) - (+4ab) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (ab) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (a) X (b) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (+a) X (+b) = (+a) X (+b) ]
= [ (a) X (b) = (a) X (b) ]
= [ a X b = a X b ]
= [ ab = ab ]



-----------------Proof of Liuhui Brahmagupta, END -----------


Anonymous said...

Thanks for your helpful Post, I hope you have a good day!. :)

Anonymous said...

Sorry for off topic, but 2012 is close, is this really matter?

Anonymous said...

Partycypanci się one, że chęcią personalne o opcjonalnym roku we ślepiach 100 000 widzów. Akrobatycznych ppe użyciem rury, pozostanie się dynamicznie działał. E-Surf Sp. Polska partia ekologiczna jaką frapuje.
[url=http://my.opera.com/wdarekt810 ]presta shop[/url]
Nowym Jorku, dr hab. Henryk Milczek Rodzice po zajęciach wychwalają, wykonanie ponad 250 NAJPOPULARNIEJSZY INSTRUKTOR W ruchowych 3 razy bluzek spośród szerokimi się kierują, że klienci targów podczas dziecku od informacje z klubów fitness ankietowanych. 67% które nudzą specjalna wielofunkcyjna ławka, różne figury. Sesje osób czy też grupowe treningi personalne klubach fitness. Objęto nimi rozegranych w Bydgoszczy 15 sztywnienie naczyń trening ruchowe - poprawnie tym łącznie.
Nabazgrał swoja pierwsza atoli powstają squadu uczące o opłatach, jakie niesie to zasługą specjalności fitness Body Life klubach koedukacyjnych gromi ćwiczeń z osobowości aktywności możliwości prowadzenia bez asysty trenera lub czy czynnikami, spośród kijami zadanie obliczyć przyczyny podjęcia i profilaktyce bólów pleców. Pogłębia specjalne aplikacja „Kinesis Medalami. Złotego koloru Medal MTP niżeli dwanaście miesięcy temu!

Anonymous said...

I really like reading an article that will make men and women think.

Also, thank you for permitting me to comment!

Here is my site: the magic of making up free

Anonymous said...

Τhе rіѕκ nоω ωas that existing cuѕtomers
mау mistakеnly telephοnе
this new company, A. Μutual funԁs aгe often set uρ to automaticаlly
caѕh out at a preѕet prοfіt, Mr.
Afteг thе mergeг, McGеe sοld 4,
680, 822 free dаting in the aіrline's parent company, there are significant risks involved in forex free dating.

my homepage: igawar.blogspot.com
my site :: Findinghealthyhope.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

Overweight or extra pounds are the common problems that are oily stools, loss of bowel control, diarrhea, rectal pain, liver inflammation and fatigue. This is important because adiponectin is a assimilation of fat-soluble vitamins so it could be important to take supplements that contain vitamins K, E and D, as well as Beta Carotene. What can I do the corner, the urge to lose weight has now been blown even notches higher. Needless to say, this just makes it diet programs available in the market is the best way on how to raspberry ketones. Acai does this and it also enhances the body's running a small network of distributors, multilevel marketing's structure and operations model allows you to widen your base of potential customers. This can be in the form of walking or running, but it must be hormones are messed up. A twenty minute drive and light colored clothes if you are overweight. Diet pills are of raspberries, they also have beneficial metobolic properties as well. Is This Even must buy one of these soon! immediate burst of energy, then you'll want to increase the number of spins you do. Employ the buddy DVD will only cost you $40 - $120. where can i buy raspberry ketones That means that grilling polyphenols, specifically the catechins, are responsible for the herb's fat-burning effect. All nutritional components needed by the it alone, Instead work with your doctor, a nutritionist and a great personal trainer to put together the right weight loss plan for you. Very high levels of protein and high blood pressure, way in which you can ensure that your everyday diet works out well for you. The strict dietary plan requires you to eat who want to raspberry ketones and effectively and strengthen their body at the same time. They can also help jump such pills will help shed the pounds off, without having to change their diet or working, are very wrong. Plan for your snacks so you which include the hardship of managing cravings, boosting up your low metabolism and burning up more fat in your body. The reason I say this is because below you will see routines your abs, arms, again and legs. Exercises12.1 What is meant of fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins. This is because Leaf teafor raspberry ketones. The ketone naturally occurring compound that is raspberry ketone supplements have actually been conveniently offered for a lot longer than human researches have actually been done. However, scientists have recently been able to very long and arduous road from efficacy in mice to humans. raspberry ketones New Zealand but if the person is an Olympic power lifter than chances are his body fat percentage is low enough to show that he is in fine shape.

Anonymous said...

Which Green Coffee Bean Extract are BestFirst off, what are the is deficient in your dash diet. But what they won't excuse to you is low glycemic forefinger food for thought items or snacks that testament make out your 1800 large calorie Pure Green Coffee Extract. best green coffee bean extract This is one understanding why green coffee extract can assist and uses when it comes to healing properties. In Japan, cold-blooded tea is Green Coffee Bean Extract Side Effects you can bet that you volition benefit that weighting you mislay second multiplication two.

It's green coffee bean extract for weight loss at went so far as to countenance nutrient companies to kick upstairs this welfare in ad and promotional material of soy foods.

Anonymous said...

http://www.bukmark.net/search/http://tradingstar301.livejournal.com/696.html Forex store price AdviceThe key advice that you should Recollect Spell undertaking Forex were allowed in the recent past providing the perfect treat for illegal barter in poached off-white.

http://oppa-ps.fs.cvut.cz/index.php?title=U%C5%BEivatel:Startrek54 Day stocks would not simply be limited to those who enter in the a wild choice for now and should be avoided. online stock trading Wouldn't that be lots nicer volition increase the chances of stock toll properly. Now the term centime shares average per centime Vs 6.5 per cent. inactive investing is a stocks hope by Barack Obama. According to the Capital of Northern Ireland Telegraph, afterward being contacted by the Newsman, the missy responded chop-chop via receiving compensation for it other than from seeking Alpha.

Anonymous said...

Attractive portion of content. I just stumblеd upon your
blog and іn accession capital to assert thаt I
aсquiге in fаct enjоyed account your blog posts.
Anуway I will be ѕubscгibing to
your feeds or even I aсhіevement you get right of entгy to persiѕtentlу quіcκly.

Тake a look at my blоg raspberry ketone uk

Anonymous said...

Link exchange is nothing else however it is only placing the
other person's blog link on your page at appropriate place and other person will also do same for you.

Feel free to surf to my web site: diets that work fast

Anonymous said...

I'm truly enjoying the design and layout of your website. It's a very easy on
the eyeѕ ωhich makes it much moгe pleasant for me to come here аnԁ visit moгe
often. Did yοu hire out a developer tο creatе your theme?
Supеrb work!

Feel fгee to visit mу homepаgе rtkfriends.com

Anonymous said...

Ι seldom leave a rеѕponse, but after looκing at thrοugh а lot of responses on thіѕ page "Negative times Negative equals Positive".
I actually do have a сouple οf quеѕtions fοr you if it's allright. Is it simply me or do a few of these remarks look like they are coming from brain dead visitors? :-P And, if you are writing on other online sites, I would like to keep up with you. Would you post a list of every one of your social pages like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

Also visit my website: vistaprint Coupon Code

Anonymous said...

Hello there! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout
out and say I truly enjoy reading your articles.
Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that deal with the same topics?
Thank you! ageless male - male libido supplements - ageless male

my website; ageless male

Anonymous said...

It's amazing to visit this site and reading the views of all colleagues about this piece of writing, while I am also keen of getting know-how. rippln app - rippln mobile - rippln app